Board Rules: Appeal Procedures
200.1 An appeal by a contractor of a final decision by the contracting officer relating to a contract dispute, a claim for interest penalties, or a decision of the Director relating to a debarment or suspension action, shall commence by the contractor filing with the Board an original and two (2) copies of a notice of appeal.
(a) In a contract dispute, no later than ninety (90) days after the contractor received the decision of the contracting officer; or, where the time period for the contracting officer to issue a decision has expired, the contractor shall file a notice of appeal within a reasonable time;
(b) In a dispute concerning suspension or debarment, no later than sixty (60) days after the contractor receives the decision of the Director to suspend or debar.
200.3 The appellant shall serve a copy of the notice of appeal on the agencies specified in Rules 202.3(a) and (b), and shall furnish the Board with proof of service.
201.1 A notice of appeal shall indicate that an appeal is being taken and shall identify the contract in dispute, or the suspension/debarment proceedings; the department or agency involved in the dispute; the decision from which the appeal is taken; the amount in dispute, if any; and shall state that the notice of appeal is timely filed.
201.3 The complaint referred to in Rule 204 may be filed with the notice of appeal, or the appellant may designate the notice of appeal as a complaint if it fulfills the requirements of a complaint.
202.2 The Board shall provide the appellant a written acknowledgment that the notice of appeal has been docketed, the case docket number, and the citation of the publication containing the current rules of the Board. In addition, the Board shall advise the appellant of the identity of the persons furnished the acknowledgment as prescribed in Rule 202.3.
(a) the Director in the case of an appeal of a debarment or suspension;
(b) the contracting officer in the case of any other appeal; and
(c) the Corporation Counsel or the counsel for the contracting agency.
202.4 The Board shall notify the contracting agency to file the appeal file as prescribed in Rule 203.
203.1 Within thirty (30) days of receipt that a notice of appeal has been docketed, the contracting agency shall assemble and transmit to the Board an appeal file consisting of all documents pertinent to the appeal, including:
(a) the decision from which the appeal is taken;
(b) the contract, including specifications and pertinent amendments, plans, and drawings;
(c) all correspondence between the parties relevant to the appeal, including the letter or letters of claim in response to which the decision was issued;
(d) transcripts of any testimony taken during the course of proceedings, and affidavits or statements of any witnesses on the matter in dispute made prior to the filing of the notice of appeal with the Board; and
(e) any additional information considered relevant to the appeal.
203.2 Within the same thirty (30) day time period, the contracting agency shall furnish the appellant a copy of each document submitted to the Board, except those in Rule 203.1(b) above. As to the latter, a list furnished appellant indicating contractual documents submitted to the Board will suffice.
203.3 Within thirty (30) days after receipt of a copy of the appeal file assembled by the contracting agency, the appellant shall transmit to the Board any documents or other tangible things not contained therein which are considered relevant to the appeal, and shall furnish a copy of each document to the attorney representing the contracting agency.
203.5 All exhibits in the appeal file shall be considered, without further action by the parties, a part of the record upon which the Board will render its decision. However, a party may object, for reasons stated, to consideration of a particular document reasonably in advance of a hearing, or, if there is no hearing, of closing the record. If an objection is made, the Board shall remove the document from the appeal file and permit the party offering the document to move its admission as evidence.
203.6 Documents in the appeal file may be originals or legible facsimiles or authenticated copies, and shall be arranged in chronological order where practicable, numbered sequentially, tabbed, and indexed to identify the contents of the file.
204.1 Within (30) days after receipt of the Board's notice that the appeal has been docketed, the appellant shall file a complaint setting forth simple, concise, and direct statements of each of its claims with the Board. If filed on paper, the appellant shall file an original and two (2) copies of the complaint with attachments.
204.2 The appellant shall set forth the basis, with appropriate reference to contract provisions and applicable law, of each claim; the dollar amount claimed, to the extent known; and the relief sought from the Board.
204.5 Should the complaint not be received by the Board within thirty (30) days after receipt of the Board's notice that the appeal has been docketed, appellant's claim and appeal may, if in the opinion of the Board the issues before the Board are sufficiently defined, be deemed to set forth its complaint and the contracting agency shall be so notified.
205.1 Within thirty (30) days from receipt of the complaint, or the notice specified in Rule 204.5, the contracting agency shall file an answer with the Board. If filed on paper, the appellant shall file an original and two (2) copies of the answer and attachments.
205.3 The answer shall set forth simple, concise and direct statements of the contracting agency's defenses to each claim asserted by the appellant, including any affirmative defenses or counterclaims available.
205.4 In lieu of answering, the contracting agency may file a dispositive motion. If the motion is filed and denied by the Board, in whole or in part, the answer shall be filed no later than thirty (30) days after the contracting agency receives the Board's ruling on the motion.
205.5 If no answer or motion is received from the contracting agency within thirty (30) days, the Board may, in its discretion, enter a general denial to the appeal, and the appellant shall be so notified, or the Board may consider the failure to answer as an admission of the claims of the appellant.
207.2 When issues within the proper scope of the appeal have not been raised by the pleadings but are tried by express or implied consent of the parties or by permission of the Board, they shall be treated in all respects as if they had been raised in the pleadings. In these instances, motions to amend the pleadings to conform to the proof may be made but are not required. If evidence is objected to at a hearing on the ground that it is not within the issues raised by the pleadings, it may be admitted within the proper scope of the appeal, provided, however, that the objecting party may be granted a continuance if necessary to enable it to meet the evidence.
208.1 After the complaint, answer, appeal file and any supplemental pleadings have been filed, each party shall inform the Board whether it desires a hearing, as prescribed by Rule 211, or whether it desires to submit its case on the record without a hearing, as prescribed by Rule 209.
210.1 The Board may, upon its own initiative, or upon application of either party, arrange for a telephone conference or direct the parties to appear before the Board at a specified time and place, prior to or during the course of a hearing, to consider the following:
(a) settlement of part or all of the dispute;
(b) the simplification of issues;
(c) the necessity or desirability of amending the pleadings;
(d) the possibility of obtaining admission of fact and stipulations concerning the use of documents to avoid unnecessary proof;
(e) the limitation of the number of witnesses;
(f) the possibility of prior mutual exchange of prepared testimony and exhibits between the parties;
(g) a schedule for the completion of discovery, if discovery is deemed necessary, and has not been completed; and
(h) any other matters that may aid in shortening the hearing on the merits and in the disposition of the appeal.
210.2 The Board shall make an order or memorandum which shall recite the action taken at the conference. This order or memorandum, when filed, shall be a part of the record in the appeal and shall control the subsequent course of the appeal unless modified by the Board.
210.4 Pleadings, discovery, and other prehearing activity shall be allowed only as consistent with the requirement to conduct the hearing on the date scheduled, or, if no hearing is scheduled, to close the record in a reasonable time. The Board, at its discretion, may impose shortened time periods for any actions prescribed or allowed under these rules.
211.2 All hearings on the merits shall be open to the public. The Board may limit access to testimony covered by a protective order entered in the case pursuant to Rule 104.
211.3 Questions concerning the admissibility of evidence and other matters that may arise in the course of the hearing shall be ruled upon by the presiding administrative judge, or, if necessary, by a majority vote of the designated panel. A decision upon the merits, or a final disposition of any appeal or part thereof, shall be by majority vote of the designated panel.
211.4 Witnesses at hearings shall be examined orally under oath or affirmation, which shall be administered by the presiding administrative judge or any member of the assigned panel. Any member of the panel may question any witness at any time during or after examination or cross-examination by the parties.
211.5 An official reporter selected by the District shall make an official transcript of the proceedings at hearings on the merits. After the close of a hearing this transcript, together with any exhibits, briefs, or other documents filed in the proceeding, shall be filed with the Board and become a part of the record.
211.6 The official reporter shall transmit copies of the transcript to the Board and the contracting agency. Copies of the official transcript shall be supplied to other parties by the official reporter at rates determined between the official reporter and the parties.
211.7 Motions to correct an official transcript shall be filed with the Board within fifteen (15) days after the receipt of the last portion of the transcript, and shall certify the date when the last portion of the transcript was received by the maker of the motion.
212.3 Briefs shall contain, in the following order, a short procedural history of the case, a table of contents, a table of authorities cited, a concise summary of argument, proposed findings of fact with citations to those places in the record where supporting evidence can be found, proposed conclusions of law with citations to supporting legal authorities, and the relief desired by the party.
213.1 The record of the appeal shall include the complaint, answer, appeal file, all motions and other submissions filed by the parties with the Board pursuant to these rules; all correspondence exchanged between the Board and the parties or their attorney; transcripts made of hearings before the Board; all exhibits and other evidence admitted to the record; and all findings, decisions, opinions, and orders of the Board.
214.1 All decisions shall be in writing and based solely on the record as prescribed in Rule 213.1.
214.2 With each decision finally disposing of an appeal or any part thereof, the Board shall file separate findings of fact and conclusions of law unless the findings of fact and conclusions of law appear therein.
(a) A contractor may appeal the Board decision to the District of Columbia Court of Appeals within one hundred twenty (120) days after the date of receipt of the Board’s decision.
(b) If the District determines that an appeal should be taken, the Director, with the prior approval of the Corporation Counsel, may appeal the Board’s decision to the District of Columbia Court of Appeals within one hundred twenty (120) days after the date of the receipt of the Board’s decision.
215.1 In an appeal where the amount in dispute is ten thousand dollars ($10,000) or less, the appellant may elect to have the appeal adjudicated under the small claims procedure set forth in this rule, or the accelerated procedure in Rule 216.
215.2 Whenever possible, decisions under the small claims procedure will be rendered within ninety (90) days from the date on which the contractor files an appeal. The election shall be stated in the notice of appeal, except that the Board for good cause may permit the election to be made after the notice of appeal is filed. Once the election is made, it may not be withdrawn except with the permission of the Board for good cause shown.
(a) Within ten (10) business days of receipt of notice of the appellant's election, the respondent shall submit to the Board a copy of the contract, the contracting agency's final decision, and the appellant's claim letter or letters; other documents from the appeal file prescribed in Rule 203 shall be submitted as the Board directs.
(b) Within fifteen (15) days after the Board has received the appellant's election, the designated administrative judge shall take the following action in an informal meeting or a telephone conference with the parties:
(1) formulate and simplify the issues;
(2) establish a simplified procedure appropriate to the appeal;
(3) determine whether either party wants a hearing, and, if so, fix a time and place;
(4) require the respondent to furnish any additional documents relevant to the appeal; and
(5) establish an expedited schedule for resolution of the appeal.
215.4 Pleadings, discovery, and other prehearing activity shall be allowed only as consistent with the requirement to conduct the hearing on the date scheduled, or, if no hearing is scheduled, to close the record on a date that will allow decisions within the 90-day limit. The Board, at its discretion, may impose shortened time periods for any actions prescribed or allowed under these rules as necessary to enable the Board to decide the appeal within the time limit.
215.5 Written decisions by the Board in cases adjudicated under the small claims (expedited) procedure shall be short and may contain abbreviated findings of fact and conclusions of law. The decisions may be rendered for the Board by a single administrative judge. A decision under the small claims procedure shall have no precedential value in future cases before the Board.
215.6 In a case where a small claims procedure has been elected and in which there has been a hearing, the administrative judge presiding at the hearing may, in the judge's discretion, at the conclusion of the hearing and after entertaining any oral arguments as deemed appropriate, render on the record oral findings of fact, conclusions of law, and a decision of the appeal.
215.7 Whenever an oral decision is rendered pursuant to Rule 215.6, the Board shall subsequently furnish the parties with a written copy of the oral decision for record and payment purposes, and to establish the starting date for the period for filing a motion for reconsideration or a judicial appeal.
216.1 In appeals where the amount in dispute is one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) or less, the appellant may elect to have the appeal adjudicated under the accelerated procedure set forth in this rule.
216.2 Decisions under the accelerated procedure shall be rendered within one hundred and eighty (180) days from the date the Board receives notice that the appellant has elected to utilize the accelerated procedure.
216.3 The appellant's election of the accelerated procedure shall be exercised by written notice within sixty (60) days after receipt of notice of docketing the appeal. The election, once exercised, may not be withdrawn, except with the permission of the Board for good cause shown.
216.4 In a case proceeding as an accelerated appeal, the Board shall encourage the parties to waive or limit pleadings, discovery, and briefs to the maximum possible extent consistent with the adequate presentation of their factual and legal positions.
216.5 Within thirty (30) days of receiving appellant's election of the accelerated procedure, the respondent shall file an answer as prescribed by Rule 205 and the appeal file as prescribed by Rule 203.
216.6 Within forty-five (45) days of receiving appellant's election of the accelerated procedure, the Board shall convene an informal meeting, or a telephone conference, with the parties and shall proceed with the case as described in Rule 215.
216.7 The Board shall permit discovery by the parties consistent with its requirement to decide their case under the time limit imposed by Rule 216.2.
(a) ADR subsequent to docketing of case at the Board. Parties are encouraged to consider the feasibility of using ADR as soon as their case is docketed. If, however, at any time during the course of a Board proceeding, the parties agree that their dispute may be resolved through the use of an ADR technique, the presiding judge may suspend proceedings for a reasonable period of time while the parties and the Board attempt to resolve the dispute in this manner. The use of an ADR technique will not toll any relevant statutory time limit for deciding the case.
(b) Other ADR. Upon request, the Board will make a Board Neutral available for an ADR proceeding involving a District agency in any contract, protest, or procurement matter at any stage of a procurement, even if no contracting officer decision has been issued or is contemplated. To initiate an ADR proceeding, the parties shall jointly request the ADR in writing and direct such request to the Chief Administrative Judge. The Board will provide ADR services on a reimbursable basis.
(a) Selection of Board Neutral. If ADR is agreed to by the parties and the Board, the parties may request the appointment of one or more Board judges to act as a Board Neutral or Neutrals. The parties may request that the Chief Administrative Judge appoint a particular judge or judges as the Board Neutral, or to appoint any judge or judges as the Neutral. If, when ADR has been requested for a case that has already been docketed with the Board, as provided in Rule 217.1(a), the parties may request that the presiding judge serve as the Board Neutral. In such situation, when the ADR is unsuccessful, (i) if the ADR has involved mediation, the presiding judge shall not retain the case, and (ii) if the ADR has not involved mediation, the presiding judge, after considering the parties' views, shall decide whether to retain the case.
(b) Retention and confidentiality of materials. The Board will review materials submitted by a party for an ADR proceeding, but will not retain such materials after the proceeding is concluded or otherwise terminated. Material created by a party for the purpose of an ADR proceeding is to be used solely for that proceeding unless the parties agree otherwise. Parties may request a protective order in an ADR proceeding in the manner provided in Rule 104.
217.3 Types of ADR. ADR is not defined by any single procedure or set of procedures. The Board will consider the use of any technique proposed by the parties which is deemed to be fair, reasonable, and in the best interest of the parties, the Board, and the resolution of disputes. The following are examples of available techniques:
(a) Mediation. The Board Neutral, as mediator, aids the parties in settling their case. The mediator engages in ex parte discussions with the parties and facilitates the transmission of settlement offers. Although not authorized to render a decision in the dispute, the mediator may discuss with the parties, on a confidential basis, the strengths and weaknesses of their positions. No judge who has participated in discussions about the mediation will participate in a Board decision of the case if the ADR is unsuccessful
(b) Neutral case evaluation. The parties agree to present to the Board Neutral information on which the Board Neutral bases a non-binding, oral, advisory opinion. The manner in which the information is presented will vary from case to case depending upon the agreement of the parties. Presentations generally fall between two extremes, ranging from an informal proffer of evidence together with limited argument from the parties to a more formal presentation of oral and documentary evidence and argument from counsel, such as through a mini-trial.
(c) Binding decision. One or more Board judges render a decision which, by prior agreement of the parties, is to be binding and non-appealable. As in the non-binding evaluation of a case by a Board Neutral, the manner in which information is presented for a binding decision may vary depending on the circumstances of the particular case.
(d) Other procedures. In addition to other ADR techniques, including modifications to those listed above, as agreed to by the Board and parties, the parties may use ADR techniques that do no require direct Board involvement.
(e) Selective use of standard procedures. Parties considering the use of ADR are encouraged to adapt for their purposes any provisions in the Board's rules which they believe will be useful. This includes but is not limited to provisions concerning record submittal, prehearing discovery procedures, and hearings.